Difference between revisions of "CVS vs SVN"

From ScummVM :: Wiki
Jump to navigation Jump to search
Line 24: Line 24:
 
* No support for versioned renames/moves (CVS repos hackery is not even remotely a replacement): Fingolfin
 
* No support for versioned renames/moves (CVS repos hackery is not even remotely a replacement): Fingolfin
 
* No proper support for directories (in particular, deleting them, but also renames/moves): Fingolfin
 
* No proper support for directories (in particular, deleting them, but also renames/moves): Fingolfin
** I want to stress that it was major hassle in history of our project: sev
+
** I want to stress that it was a major hassle in history of our project: sev
  
 
=== See Also ===
 
=== See Also ===
 
* [http://svnbook.red-bean.com/en/1.1/apa.html Subversion for CVS Users] - Lists the major differences. Taken from the svn book
 
* [http://svnbook.red-bean.com/en/1.1/apa.html Subversion for CVS Users] - Lists the major differences. Taken from the svn book

Revision as of 23:14, 20 January 2006

On this page, we are trying to collect argument pro and contra both staying with CVS, and switching to CVS. Behind each "argument" is a list of people who agree that this particular argument is valid. We currently have no other realistic choices (since SF.net offers us exactly those two), so I am not comparing more systems here.


Pro Subversion

  • Support for versioned renames/moves (impossible with CVS): Fingolfin
  • Supports directories natively: It's possible to remove them, and they are versioned: Fingolfin
  • File properties are versioned; no more "executable bit" hell: Fingolfin
  • Overall revision number makes build versioning and regression testing much easier: Ender, Fingolfin
  • Atomic commits: Fingolfin
  • Intuitive (directory-based) branching and tagging: Fingolfin
  • Easier hook scripts (pre/post commit, etc): SumthinWicked (I use it for Doxygen after commits)
  • Prevents accidental committing of conflicted files: Salty-horse, Fingolfin
  • Support for custom 'diff' command: Fingolfin

Pro CVS

  • Lots of people know how to use it: Fingolfin
  • Lots of documentation available: Fingolfin

Contra Subversion

  • Takes up twice as much disk space: Fingolfin
  • We need to put efforts into transferring repository to it: sev

Contra CVS

  • No support for versioned renames/moves (CVS repos hackery is not even remotely a replacement): Fingolfin
  • No proper support for directories (in particular, deleting them, but also renames/moves): Fingolfin
    • I want to stress that it was a major hassle in history of our project: sev

See Also